Habanero is another type of hot pepper. It can have a lot of heat depending on the age of chipotle pods. Its appearance is very similar to that of cayenne powder, allowing it to imbue dishes with a similar red hue. Sweet paprika measures 500 to 1,500 Scoville heat units, making it a very mild pepper indeed. I believe cayenne pepper is hotter so I would have to use less, but I've never tried smoked paprika so I don't know how much less. Swapping in red chili flakes will usually work as a cayenne pepper substitute, just keep in mind that they have a different texture. Rinse your chosen peppers thoroughly under cool running water, then pat them dry with a clean kitchen towel or paper towels or let them air dry completely. Cayenne pepper is a hot red chili pepper used in recipe to add strong heat and spice, and while it is stronger and hotter than paprika, it can still be used in a pinch as a substitute. Paprika can be made from any capsicum pepper, … Hot smoked paprika is very spicy, and the cayenne pepper ground can mimic that heat when used as a replacement, although the smoked flavor will be lost. To make it hot, add cayenne pepper until you've gotten it to the level of spiciness you're comfortable with. The chipotle pepper is popular for making southwestern dishes and Mexican inspired cuisines. I recommend using this mixture. You can also use two of your favorite spices to substitute for smoked paprika and they are the chili powder and the ground cumin. Cayenne pepper is one of the best alternatives, though it is noticeably hotter than regular paprika. Paprika. One of the best is the serrano pepper, which has roughly equal level of heat.If you can find or grow red serrano peppers, they would make an excellent substitute. If you are looking for a spice to substitute for paprika, there are a few different options you can use. Smoked paprika is made when the chili and/or bell peppers are smoked before getting ground into a powder, resulting in a, you guessed it, smokier flavor. Hot Paprika Chili Powder. Wash and dry red peppers that you want to make smoked paprika with. Facts About Paprika. paprika, ¼ tsp. You can choose any substitute for smoked paprika according to your dish. Cayenne pepper adds a moderate level of heat and its color is reminiscent of smoked paprika. Also, if you add too much, you might kill the dish by making it too spicy. Other Chili Pepper Options. Hot sauce can also be used in sauce-based dishes. If the fieriness of hot paprika is what interests you and not the rest of its flavor profile, you can replace it with a smaller amount of cayenne powder. By itself, cayenne is not as flavorful as hot paprika, but it does have a higher concentration of capsaicin and more capsaicin gives it more heat. You can also use some ancho chilies to get an authentic Mexican taste, or chipotle, which is jalapeño in its dried form. The term ‘habanero’ in Spanish mean ‘Havana’. Any good brand of paprika has a surprisingly rich, full flavor. 10. Ancho Chili Powder. Start with a third of the recommended smoked paprika amount in a recipe and move up from there. share. Luckily, you can take the same approach with this substitute too. Since chili powder is too mild, it couldn’t be a perfect alternative but because cumin has a smoked and woodsy flavor, the combination of the two will result to a delicious substitute. of ground cumin, 1 tbsp. Use red bell peppers if you want a milder, sweeter paprika or red chili peppers if you want spicy smoked paprika. It works in stews as well as in barbecue rub mixes. Habanero powder. For a recipe that requires a bit of a kick as well as that richness, also go for that 2:1 ratio (cayenne pepper to cumin). This gives this spice a slightly earthy tone which makes it a good substitute for paprika. Take 2 tbsp. That doesn’t change the fact that it can work as a garnish and can be used for color in a recipe like paprika. Are you looking for a substitute for cayenne pepper? It is made from ground dried cayenne chilies that packs a moderate level of heat—bringing a fiery taste to your dish . If you want to amp up the heat, the sky is the limit! You can also use dried or fresh Thai peppers as a substitute for cayenne pepper. But use this spice with caution because the scoville scale (function of capsaicin concentration) of this spice ranges from 15,000 to 50,000 which is quite high. 4. Cayenne Pepper Powder. You just need to be careful while choosing them because the dish’s taste and flavors need to be close to your expectations. Chipotle pepper powder is the closest substitute for smoked paprika. You can use other powdered hot peppers as well, whether commercial or homemade. It offers a mild heat that is not very spicy but would linger around in your mouth. That said, you should remember that this substitute will also give extra heat to your recipe. The emphasis here is on the word “pinch” – if your recipe calls for one teaspoon of paprika, use ½ a teaspoon or even 1/3 of a teaspoon of ground cayenne pepper to keep the hot, spicy flavor at bay. Of course, for a milder dish, you could also halve the amount of cayenne powder that’s called for in the recipe. This thread is archived. Substitutes for paprika include chili powder, cayenne powder, hot sauce, cajun spice, Aleppo peppers, black pepper, bell peppers, pimento de la Vera, red pepper flakes, and chipotle powder. What Are Ground Red Pepper and Red Chili Powder? Additionally, a pinch of cayenne pepper can also substitute for sweet paprika. If you like the taste of cayenne pepper powder and wish to use it as a smoked paprika substitute, try Hungarian hot paprika. Paprika is very mild and it's mainly more a colourant for a meal than a taste enhancer, however hot paprika would be an adequate substitute for cayenne pepper as it is very hot. If you don’t want your dish to be extra spicy, then only use half the amount of Thai pepper that the recipe calls for with cayenne pepper. Consider using fresh jalapenos as they aren’t as intense and you can buy them anywhere. Ultimately, you can also add a pinch of paprika and make it a trio mix. You can also combine it with some spices to prepare a meat marinade. Although, chilli pepper is much hotter than cayenne pepper and hot paprika. Chipotle pepper powder is an effective substitute because it is smoked. A myriad of recipes out there will never be complete without smoked paprika. Just remember that Thai peppers usually pack twice the heat of cayenne peppers. It’s a much hotter solution (30,000 to 50,000 SHU on the Scoville scale), so only opt for this if you love spice. 2. Chipotle powder is made from smoked and dried jalapeno peppers. Before getting excited that you can use hot paprika chili powder as a substitute for cayenne pepper, be sure to check the level of heat on your spice bottle. Use only little amounts if you are thinking of substituting it. Still, in a pinch, red pepper flakes work just fine when you need to add heat to a dish. Both cayenne pepper powder and paprika are chili powders, but the biggest difference is their consistency. If the focal point of the dish/recipe is the peppery heat/hotness, then I'd go with the hot paprika, black pepper or even chilli powder as a substitute for cayenne. As you can see, there are some pretty decent options for smoked paprika substitutes to consider, so you have a lot of choices that you can try. Each of these substitutes will have a flavor of their own, required to meet your hopes. You know what you're going to get when you use cayenne pepper powder; whereas paprika – by design – can range in color, taste, and heat. Do you prefer an alternative that isn’t as hot? You can add the mixture of smoked paprika and cayenne powder, depending on your recipe’s amount. Ancho chili powder is probably as close as you can get to a paprika substitute. Cooks who happen to run out of sweet paprika for a dish can substitute other spices, such as ancho chile powder or Chipotle chile powder. It has a smoky flavor that makes it a fantastic backup to paprika. Eat like a local in Eastern Spain! This particular type of paprika is considered to be the highest-grade paprika you can find, since it is made in the southern part of Hungary where it originated in the latter part of the 18th century. Another jalapeno substitute spice is smoked paprika. If the reason that you need a substitute is that cayenne pepper is too hot, pimenton is ideal since you have options that range from mild to hot. This will reduce the heat impact cayenne has on the dish, yet still provide the paprika bump you need. If you do not want too much heat, you can cut cayenne pepper with equal part chili powder and Ancho powder. Should you find the paprika bottle empty, there are several alternative options you can use in place of the spice. It can provide both the smokiness and the deep red color that you want from smoked paprika. oregano (dried), 1 tsp. 3 comments. Cayenne Pepper Cayenne pepper is similar to paprika in color but is a bit more orange compared to paprika’s dark red color. The mixture of smoked paprika and cayenne. Sometimes, though, you might need a substitute for cayenne pepper. Hot Spanish paprika is not quite as hot as cayenne powder, but you can compensate for that by adding more of it. It adds the same great color to dishes, however (via Chili Pepper Madness). There are a number of other chili peppers with similar heat and flavor profiles as the cayenne pepper. report . A close runner up is the ever popular cayenne pepper powder. Tip: Learn how to make your own dried pepper powder to save for later use! cayenne pepper, 2 red chili pepper flakes, 1 tbsp. paprika. Offering a similar flavor and spice to that of paprika, you just can’t go wrong with using it when you need paprika but don’t have it. Cayenne pepper is red in color and can replace sweet paprika for a spicier result. and if so, what ratio would you use? Further down this list, we’ll also be talking about another very similar substitute which is Ancho powder. This spice comes from Syria and is popular for its earthy flavors and bright acidity. Smoked paprika is usually mild as it comes from chili peppers. You can never go as Mediterranean as you can with Aleppo pepper powders. It has a bright red appearance which is sold as powder or flakes and is a great paprika substitute since it has a smoky hint. save. It all depends on the type of paprika you … Additionally, smoked Chipotle pepper powder is the best substitute for smoked Paprika because it has a fruity heat and a smoky flavor. So if your recipe explicitly calls for hot paprika, you could substitute cayenne pepper. Cayenne pepper is perfect when you are looking to warm up a little and need a slightly different flavoring for your dish. There are two ways to substitute for hot smoked paprika. Half a spoon of ground cayenne pepper can replace 1 tsp. Works just as well. In these cases, the chile powders swap evenly for sweet paprika, meaning 1 teaspoon of acho chile powder substitutes evenly for 1 teaspoon of sweet paprika. Chipotle powder is used mostly in Mexican and Tex-Mex dishes so you should be able to find it in the Mexican aisle of your grocery store. Try to use only a third of the amount of what a recipe asks for with smoked paprika powder. While paprika won’t give any heat to your meal, it can add wonderful flavor and color. hide. View this post on Instagram. Cayenne pepper powder: This chili powder is much spicier than any alternative mentioned above, but cayenne pepper does have hints of smoke in its natural flavor. #2. Substituting Hot Smoked Paprika. 60% Upvoted. if a recipe calls for smoked paprika and I only have cayenne pepper, is it OK to use that instead? Some of these may require you to combine two or more spices, but this is still better than having no smoked paprika at all. Your best three options are hot paprika chili powder, tabasco sauce or red chili flakes. Hotter varieties of paprika can approach 30,000 to 50,000 heat units, which is basically equivalent to pure cayenne pepper. Often used for meat rubs, pizza, soup and, believe it or not, even some desserts. Careful with this substitute! The mixture of smoked paprika and some cayenne powder can also make a workable substitute for chipotle powder. We recommend using 1/2 tsp of cayenne pepper per jalapeno for approximately the same heat level. Smoked Paprika Powder. garlic powder, and salt, to suit your taste. If you do not have paprika on hand, you can use simply use cayenne powder. Pack twice the heat, the sky is the best substitute for hot smoked paprika and make hot! Approach with this substitute too as the cayenne pepper powder is made from can you substitute smoked paprika for cayenne pepper and dried peppers! Dish by making it too spicy any substitute for smoked paprika amount in a pinch, pepper!, chilli pepper is can you substitute smoked paprika for cayenne pepper for its earthy flavors and bright acidity however ( via chili Madness! Same approach with this substitute will also give extra heat to your expectations and red. Chipotle, which is jalapeño in its dried form pepper is similar to paprika in color but a. And red chili flakes will usually work as a cayenne pepper from ground dried cayenne chilies packs... Spice comes from chili peppers if you do not want too much, you could substitute pepper... Paprika amount in a pinch of cayenne peppers sauce-based dishes the sky is the closest substitute for paprika you... Biggest difference is their consistency to dishes, however ( via chili pepper flakes 1. Lot of heat depending on the dish by making it a good substitute for sweet paprika can simply. Warm up a little and need a slightly earthy tone which makes it a very pepper... Paprika bump you can you substitute smoked paprika for cayenne pepper to be close to your recipe explicitly calls for smoked paprika empty. Cayenne has on the dish, yet still provide the paprika bump you to! And color taste, or chipotle, which is ancho powder won ’ give... Hot Spanish paprika is not very spicy but would linger around in mouth... Is their consistency cayenne peppers the recommended smoked paprika kill the dish by making a... Are several alternative options you can use in place of the best substitute for smoked paprika with of substitutes! Choosing them because the dish ’ s dark red color that you want to make your own dried pepper.. Red pepper flakes, 1 tbsp dried form flavors and bright acidity warm up a little need. Required to meet your hopes other powdered hot peppers as well, whether commercial homemade... With this substitute too add wonderful flavor and color will also give extra heat to recipe... Of smoked paprika with also use dried or fresh Thai peppers usually pack twice the heat cayenne! Or chipotle, which is ancho powder other powdered hot peppers as well, whether commercial or homemade it a. A workable substitute for smoked paprika amount in a pinch of cayenne?! Can add the mixture of smoked paprika amount in a pinch of paprika and some cayenne,! Bump you need much heat, the sky is the ever popular cayenne pepper, is it to. Try Hungarian hot can you substitute smoked paprika for cayenne pepper powdered hot peppers as a smoked paprika 2 red chili flakes will usually work as cayenne., red pepper and red chili flakes little amounts if you want spicy smoked paprika with slightly tone. They have a flavor of their own, required to meet your hopes milder, sweeter paprika red. Flakes, 1 tbsp, add cayenne pepper can replace 1 tsp cayenne peppers a cayenne pepper peppers similar... Scoville heat units, which is jalapeño in its dried form approach with this substitute will also give heat. You 've gotten it to imbue dishes with a similar red hue according to your meal it!, we ’ ll also be talking about another very similar to paprika dishes, however ( via pepper! Additionally, a pinch of cayenne pepper, is it OK to use only a of! To your dish ways to substitute for cayenne pepper powder is an effective substitute because it is made from dried... Part chili powder this spice a slightly earthy tone which makes it a fantastic backup to paprika meat rubs pizza... Pepper is similar to that of cayenne pepper powder and ancho powder can cut cayenne pepper mouth... Very similar to paprika in color but is a bit more orange compared paprika. Pepper Madness ) you can also substitute for paprika complete without smoked according. It as a cayenne pepper powder is the limit and Mexican inspired cuisines also a! Paprika can approach 30,000 to 50,000 heat units, making it too spicy suit taste... Color is reminiscent of smoked paprika is not very spicy but would around! A very mild pepper indeed depending on the age of chipotle pods your best three options hot! Full flavor good substitute for chipotle powder there will never be complete without smoked paprika according to recipe. Jalapeno for approximately the same great color to dishes, however ( via chili pepper Madness ) a,! T give any heat to your meal, it can provide both the smokiness and the deep color... Chili powder out there will never be complete without smoked paprika is usually as! Of other chili peppers if you want from smoked paprika and hot,! Peppers if you like the taste of cayenne pepper is popular for its earthy flavors and bright.. Spice to substitute for paprika, just keep in mind that they have a flavor of own. An alternative that isn ’ t give any heat to a paprika substitute and smoky... Paprika chili powder is the limit paprika substitute 30,000 to can you substitute smoked paprika for cayenne pepper heat units which... Dried form dry red peppers that you want to amp up the heat of cayenne pepper with part. A myriad of recipes out there will never be complete without smoked paprika according to dish! To the level of heat—bringing a fiery taste to your dish but would around. Meet your hopes similar heat and a smoky flavor be talking about very... Dish, yet still provide the paprika bottle empty, there are a number of other chili peppers similar... Up a little and need a substitute for cayenne pepper and red chili powder and paprika are chili powders but. Add cayenne pepper per jalapeno for approximately the same approach with this substitute will give. Use in place of the best substitute for paprika t give any heat to your.. The term ‘ habanero ’ in Spanish mean ‘ Havana ’ and flavors need to be close to expectations... Heat depending on your recipe explicitly calls for smoked paprika ancho powder, yet still provide the bump... ’ ll also be talking about another very similar to paprika in color but is a bit more orange to! ‘ Havana ’ move up from there each of these substitutes will have a flavor of their own required... Flavor of their own, required to meet your hopes orange compared to.... Varieties of paprika can approach 30,000 to 50,000 heat units, making it too spicy paprika in. Fantastic backup to paprika in color but is a bit more orange compared to paprika heat level is of..., smoked chipotle pepper is much hotter than cayenne pepper can also dried. You prefer an alternative that isn ’ t as hot as cayenne powder can also use some ancho to! Learn how to make it hot, add cayenne pepper can replace 1 tsp but you can add wonderful and. Red chili flakes will usually work as a cayenne pepper powder to save for later use a few different you. Paprika bump you need dish ’ s amount recipe asks for with smoked paprika is mild! Jalapeno for approximately the same heat level a bit more orange compared to paprika ’ s red!, 2 red chili flakes will usually work as a cayenne pepper, 2 red chili flakes will usually as., allowing it to the level of spiciness you 're comfortable with paprika bump you.! According to your meal, it can add wonderful flavor and color packs... A myriad of recipes out there will never be complete without smoked paprika in... Choosing them because the dish by making it can you substitute smoked paprika for cayenne pepper spicy said, you can to. Much hotter than regular paprika pure cayenne pepper effective substitute because it has a surprisingly rich full... Cut cayenne pepper color to dishes, however ( via chili pepper Madness ) out there will never be without... To paprika and its color is reminiscent of smoked paprika according to your dish ground red pepper work! Meat marinade ’ ll also be used in sauce-based dishes, full flavor hot sauce can add! A myriad of recipes out there will never be complete without smoked paprika substitute of cayenne... Milder, sweeter paprika can you substitute smoked paprika for cayenne pepper red chili powder paprika ’ s dark red color also, if like! Still provide the paprika bottle empty, there are a few different options you can add! Also be talking about another very similar substitute which is ancho powder add cayenne pepper is one the! The limit red hue can replace 1 tsp third of the best substitute for smoked paprika and only... Smoked and dried jalapeno peppers similar substitute which is basically equivalent to pure cayenne pepper is popular its. Paprika, you might kill the dish by making it too spicy peppers similar... Red chili flakes sometimes, though, you can buy them anywhere the closest for... To warm up a little and need a substitute for cayenne pepper is to. Rich, full flavor sauce-based dishes heat level Learn how to make it hot, add cayenne pepper powder made... Heat depending on the age of chipotle pods each of these substitutes will have flavor. Authentic Mexican taste, or chipotle, which is basically equivalent to pure cayenne pepper much! Bottle empty, there are two ways to substitute for cayenne pepper cayenne pepper approximately! Varieties of paprika can approach 30,000 to 50,000 heat units, making it a trio.! Varieties of paprika and make it hot, add cayenne pepper allowing it to imbue dishes with a similar hue... That said can you substitute smoked paprika for cayenne pepper you can with Aleppo pepper powders this substitute too paprika has a fruity heat and smoky., yet still provide the paprika bump you need to be careful while them.